Re: FW: Review of draft-nakhjiri-radius-mip4-01.txt

[Bernard Aboba <aboba@internaut.com>]

The Nakhjiri document has not been discussed in RADEXT WG, although it was 
brought up in a 3GPP2 liaison request.  At that time, the question arose 
as to whether this was a legitimate dependency or not -- as I recall, 
3GPP2 had already defined VSAs for use of MIPv4 within RADIUS, so it 
wasn't clear whether this document, if developed would be deployed. 

Also, concerns were raised about whether the document could meet the 
AAA Key Management requirements. 

On Thu, 13 Oct 2005, Jari Arkko wrote:

> I reviewed this draft for the mobility directorate, as
> its attempting to become a WG item in the MIP4 WG.
> See review below.
> 
> Does anyone else want to comment on this? Was there
> a history of this draft in RADEXT, or has anyone reviewed
> this in the AAA Doctors team?
> 
> -------