[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Draft minutes from Tove
Hi Adrian and all,
just some notes about the minutes from Tove:
> 11. Diverse Inter-region Setup - D'Achille - presented by Adrian (5 min)
>
<http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-dachille-inter-region-path-setup-
> 04.txt>
> -- Adrian not that familiar with this draft. Flags one slide on message
> exchange where the head end is in the center rather than at the end.
In the presentation
(http://home.clara.net/olddog/61/draft-achille-diverse-inter-region-path-setup-01-v3.ppt)
slide 3 the figure is actually correct because it illustrates the same
node (head-end) on two sides of the source, to show how the ARO can be
flipped to become the ERO.
WRT
> 12. Related to 11. Protection for Inter-AS tunnels - Decnodder - Cristel
> Pelsser
>
<http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-decnodder-ccamp-interas-protectio
> n-00.txt>
> -- Differs from 11, addresses requirements from TEWG draft
We want stress that ARO addresses requirements from the TEWG draft too
(draft-ietf-tewg-interas-mpls-te-req-09.txt), in particular is in
accordance with Section:
5.1.1. Inter-AS MPLS TE Operations and Interoperability
5.1.5. Re-optimization
5.1.8. Scalability and Hierarchical LSP Support
5.1.11. Extensibility
6. Security Considerations
This was also the basis on which we got some good feedback
from the service provider community in the extensive discussions
before, during, and after Seoul.
May be we need to better point out this issue in the next version of the
draft.
Finally the phrase "need further feedback" looks not clear, who needs
feedback? -the list or the authors ?-
Best Regards
Ugo Monaco
--
*********************************************************************
Ugo Monaco INFOCOM Dept.
Ph.D. Student Via Eudossiana, 18
Phone: +39-06-47825184 00184 Roma (Italy)
E-mail: monaco@infocom.uniroma1.it Fax: +39-06-48930606
*********************************************************************