RE: Moving forward with the CCAMP charter

["CHO, JAI HYUNG" <jaihyung@etri.re.kr>]

Hi, Adrian
 
Thank you for your milestone work.
However, I can not find L2SC work in your document.
Where does it belong to ?
I believe there's some number of people supporting thie work
and also we see clear industry need for this work.
I think it would be good if we have L2SC milestone
at least for framework and solution document.
 
thanks
 
Jaihyung
 

Dr. Jaihyung Cho
ETRI, Korea
phone :       042) 860-5514
oversea: +82-42-860-5514
fax:         +82-42-861-5550 




-----?? ???----- 
From: "Adrian Farrel" <adrian@olddog.co.uk> 
From Date: 2005-08-16 ?? 8:28:11 
To: "ccamp@ops.ietf.org" <ccamp@ops.ietf.org> 
Cc: "zinin@psg.com" <zinin@psg.com>, "'Kireeti Kompella'" <kireeti@juniper.net> 
Subject: Moving forward with the CCAMP charter 

Hi, 

Please find attached a file that contains: 

- a set of proposed *draft* milestones 
- a discussion of why there are so many milestones 
- a high-level explanation of the work items. 

Note that this looks like a lot of milestones, but please read the text on this issue in the attached file. The bottom line is that this is a product of micro management where I have tried to identify all of the I-Ds that we might produce to cover the referenced work, and where I have placed two (sometimes three) milestones for each I-D. 

This micro-management may be over the top, and represents a full pendulum swing from the previous style of CCAMP milestones, but in the light of the hiatus of the last 12 months, i think this may be beneficial and might achieve rapid forwards movement. 

I would welcome your (constructive!) comments. 

Notes: 
- Why isn't my I-D also cited as input material? 
 No insult intended. The current list is simply there to 
 show the ADs that work is already in progress. All I-Ds 
 will be used as input.      
- Why isn't my pet topic included?
  Are you sure it is not there between the lines? This 
  list of milestones isn't completely proscriptive.
  
The objective is to have the WG agreed on the milestones that it wants to commit to by the end of August.
 
Thanks,
Adrian