Re: [idn] IDN rechartering rev 3

["James Seng/Personal" <jseng@pobox.org.sg>]

Eric,

Rechartering takes a while..we are still thrashing the wordings. If you
have any proposed wording changes, then please provide them. Saying you
"disagree" or "I dont like this" does not help me when I am trying to
tune the changes. It is much easier if you are more explicit.

Personally, I feel that there are a few sentence which I feel should be
dropped or change. See below.

> > In particular, changes
> > to the DNS infrastructure of storage and exchange mechanisms will
> > be avoided.

This one should be dropped.

> > The technical approach for the current specification effort shall be
to
> > permit use of international character, as recommended by the IAB,
and

This is vague cos I dont know what recommendation from IAB Dave is
refering to.

> > In particular software that needs to
> > be changed is restricted to:  DNS client.  No other modules will
need
> > to be changed.

This should be drop too.

-James Seng