Re: [idn] IDN rechartering rev 3, and nameprep

["James Seng/Personal" <jseng@pobox.org.sg>]

> The solution I proposed above avoids the problem, and has no
significant
> disadvantages in the context of IDN. It is a straightforward change to
> the nameprep folding table, that stays within the current model of a
> stringprep profile. I'm certainly not suggesting redesigning NFC or
NFKC.

In this case, I suggest you follow up with the Nameprep Design team. I
have cc: them above.

> Am I reading the same document:
>
<http://www.i-d-n.net/ietf49/idn-sandiego-nameprep-design-team-report.pp
t>?

Yes, the note is brief. But the presentation is much more in detail.

Anyway, I am probably interested in one point. :-)

> > Goal & Milestone:
> > Nov 2001        domain name identifiers normalization draft last
call
>
> This is completely unrealistic. There are many unresolved issues
concerning
> normalisation.

What would you counter propose to make this realistic?

-James Seng