[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [idn] Re: idn-uri document
I came in here just to say two things as a "user"
- the punycode thing seems OK but the DNS aspects are
inadequate"
- the text you produced is not easily understandable.
I was said to be a troll for the second point. May be
could we also look at the second one?
At 19:23 05/11/02, John C Klensin wrote:
--On Thursday, 31 October, 2002 23:40 +0100 Erik Nordmark
But, even in that case, we haven't permitted profile variations _within_
IDNA: a user, site, or registry cannot select a different stringprep
profile, and that is a Good, probably necessary, thing.
"probably" necessary ???
At this date, this rises a lot of question.
All I found was a very early commitment to that in the process.
I did not read everythng yet.
Any reason why it is "certainly" necessary?
(a part from obvious non technical reasons)
But much the same argument applies to the type of use Martin
contemplates. IDNA, as written, is _one_ protocol. It is not
a toolkit for building other protocols, nor is it a a set of
profiles that other protocols can adopt. Those two may be much
the same thing in practice. As soon as we say "you should use
that operation from IDNA, but without some particular step" we
head down a slippery slope. That is especially true because
IDNA contains (or appears to contain) a good deal of normative
text outside the particular of, e.g., ToASCII. It is not clear
whether "...explicitly state that one should apply ToASCII
without the punycode step (and other steps..." includes some,
all, or none of those textual specifications. And, whatever
choice is made, "do just what is done over there, except..." is
a poor way to do protocol specification and introduces some of
the worst properties of profiling without any of the benefits of
being explicit about what can, and cannot, be profiled.
You point is accepted. But to say that applying ToASCII to
a valid ASCII name is equivalent to do nothing does not
removes the need to use ToASCII, but helps understanding
that this is what actually happens. The way it is written leaves
many questions open.
jfc