Error in checklist item #7 of <draft-ietf-ops-mib-review-guidelines-01.txt>

["C. M. Heard" <heard@pobox.com>]

Hello,

Item #7 of Appendix A:  MIB Review Checklist currently reads as follows:

 7.) IANA Considerations Section -- if the draft contains the initial
 version of an IANA-maintained module, verify that the MODULE-IDENTITY
 invocation contains maintenance instructions that comply with RFC
 2434.  Note that module itself must be in an appendix that will
 disappear after publication and that the IANA Considerations section
 that will appear in the RFC must contain a pointer to that module.

This is not consistent with Section 3.7, which states that the initial
version of an IANA-maintained MIB modules will be published in the RFC
that introduces that module.  The following rewording is suggested to
correct this problem:

 7.) IANA Considerations Section -- if the draft contains the initial
 version of an IANA-maintained module, verify that the MODULE-IDENTITY
 invocation contains maintenance instructions that comply with RFC
 2434.  Note that the IANA Considerations section that will appear in
 the RFC must contain a pointer to that module.

Regards,

Mike Heard