Re: Minutes / Notes

[Masataka Ohta <mohta@necom830.hpcl.titech.ac.jp>]

Iljitsch;

> >> I have a few technical (not editorial) comments on some points in the 
> >> minutes,
> >> which are therefore of general interest...
> 
> > A problem is that the minutes lacks discussioin on so many errors of
> > Iljitsch's proposal that yo are repeating my points at the meeting
> 
> Well, let's hear it then. What are those errors?

1) On slide of "loc/id separation", the mapping from FQDN should not be

	FQDN -> ID -> Locators

but should be

	FQDN -> (ID, Locators)

to avoid extra mapping and possible security problem.

2) On slide of pros and cons of "small", all the "cons" are wrong as follows.

	2.1) Work with unaggregatable MAC namespace
	or break autoconfiguration

	Structured ID can be autoconfigured by DHCP.


	2.2) Can't trust incoming id-loc association

	Association between an ID and locators is secure if they
	are contained in a single packet.

	2.3) If not break, certainly bend transports

	With LIN6 trick, API for TCP stays same.

	2.4) Changes to both hosts and routers

	There is no changes to routers

There are other errors I didn't bothered to correct.

							Masataka Ohta