Re: on the point of mobility & multihoming

[David Kessens <david@iprg.nokia.com>]

Ohta-san,

On Thu, Mar 11, 2004 at 08:15:01AM +0900, Masataka Ohta wrote:
> 
> As both of you are responsible for choosing Geoff as the
> presenter and wasted our time, it is not surprising that you
> don't admit your faults and react even against words in Kurt's
> own mouth.
> 
> However, with no technical content, your reactions are
> no constructive.
> 
> Just admit the technical fact that Geoff's presentation was
> technically poor and misdirected, for which both of you
> are guilty.

The multi6 working group is trying to tackle a very hard problem. The
differences between the proposals are huge. Despite all this, we have
had very good discussions without any personal attacks except for
yours.

Due to the diversity of opinions, it is inevitable that there are
occasional disagreements. It's ok to disagree. It is not ok to
verbally assault the person that you disagree with. It is not
necessary to repeat your opinion over and over again in a very
aggressive manner while it is clear that there is no significant
support for your opinion.

Your attacks on the chairpeople, Geoff and many other contributors to
this working group are inappropriate and should stop.

I think that the whole working group and the chairpeople are doing a
great job. We know that you have interesting ideas, please help the
group by contributing to the working group in a civil manner so that
the working group can focus on the problems that need to be solved.

Thanks,

David Kessens
---