[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Comments on draft-nordmark-multi6-threats-01




El 11/06/2004, a las 1:39, Noel Chiappa escribió:


From: "Fleischman, Eric" <eric.fleischman@boeing.com>

identifier  - an IP layer identifier for an IP layer endpoint
			(stack name in [NSRG]).

I am bothered by this definition. The way I read it, it implies that an
IP layer endpoint is the protocol stack. That is true of every protocol
system that I know (including OSI) except for the Internet protocol
suite. For the Internet protocol suite, the IP layer endpoint is a
network interface.

To start with, terminology nit - and lest you think terminology nits are not
worthy of notice, let me yet again roll out one of my faourite quotations:


"I am far from thinking that nomenclature is a remedy for every defect in
art or science: still I cannot but feel that confusion of terms generally
springs from, and always leads to, confusion of ideas."


-- John Louis Petit, "Architectural Studies in France", 1854


i still think that sooner or later we will need a terminology draft so we all share the same definitions when we use certain words
i know that this will probably imply long discussions about which words to use, though


Regards, marcelo