RE: AD review of: draft-ietf-tewg-measure-05.txt

["Ash, Gerald R (Jerry), ALABS" <gash@att.com>]

Jim,

> A bit of background - this WG item was intended to make the essential 
> measurements needed well defined enough that the way these "entities" were 
> measured across implementations (e.g. vendors) would be consistent.  

Yes, a critical need.

<...>

> I recommend we do the following clean up
> 
> - Somewhere provide a CRISP set of recommendations

Yes.

> - Remove all discussion which does not directly re-enforce a recommendation

Or move the discussion to an Annex if it is useful in supporting the recommendations.

>   - Maybe one option will be to remove the WG item completely

Disagree.  The need is important (some say 'critical'), I don't recall anyone saying the WG item in not important and should be dropped.

Thanks,
Jerry