Re: comment on draft-lind-v6ops-isp-scenarios-00.txt

[Jasminko Mulahusic <jasko@fakat.com>]

On Wed, 16 Jul 2003, HELENA RUTE SOFIA wrote:

> It seems to me that 1. and 2. could simply start by an analysis of current
> deployed solutions; trying to exhaustively cover the possible situations
> that could be a representative subset of real scenarios, to provide some
> "howto" is an endless task, and would take so long, that it would probably
> not make much sense in the end...also, different ISPs not only have
> different sizes, use different technologies, but also have different
> purposes in terms of offered services; and, we also have commercial
> services and research services...
>

true. the thing is that we are not sure if there are any isps that have
deployed fully commercial v6 networks, operated in the same way as their
v4 networks. and even if we could find them it is not sure they would be
able to share the results with us.

jasminko

> So, as was also mentioned yesterday at the v6ops meeting, why not simply
> change the document to provide an analysis of current scenarios? I'm
> pretty sure that it doesn't cost much to some ISPs of different sizes to
> provide some input on a draft that somebody could put together...
>
> Ch.,
> rute
>
>
>