[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: axfr-clarify's fraudulent claims of consensus



D. J. Bernstein wrote:
The IETF shouldn't be sticking its nose into private
implementation decisions that don't cause interoperability problems.
But Rob Elz made a clear point in seemingly the only message you *didn't* respond to that your implementation could cause interoperability problems by potentially allowing for different contents of the same zone with the same serial number. I won't regurgitate the rest of his message, but it's in the archives.

If he's right (and it seems to me that he is), that's an indication for either a standards clarification or a bug fix to your code, and maybe both (indicated, IMHO).

Eliot