draft-vaudreuil-mdnbis-03.txt

[Ted Hardie <hardie@qualcomm.com>]

DISCUSS

The change control section indicates that "denied" and
"failed" were deleted, but they are still in the collected
grammar in section 7.

original-message id

in the same section seems to be missing an operator.


Is the advice in section 8.3, paragraph 2 also applicable
to cases where a list rewrites the From: field?

Should we specify the code points allowed for section
9.1, c), or is "graphic US-ASCII characters" enough?


Are all references normative?


Notes:

the examples use non example.com style fqdns.

The risk of "mail bombing" is noted in 2.1, but not listed in the
security considerations.

Is the advice in 3.2.1 noting that the DNS name of the particular
instance of the MUA should be in the Reporting-UA field
still valid?

There is a missing closing paren on (e.g. "X Foomail
at the end of section 3.3.