Re: FW: AD response to Site-Local Appeal

[Keith Moore <moore@cs.utk.edu>]

Tony,

there was strong concensus in the WG to deprecate SL.  by asking for
this declaration to be repealed you are asking for your own will and the
will of a small minority to override the consensus of this WG and the
extended IETF community.  not only would this be a grave technical
error, it would be a gross violation of IETF process.

in short, your request is ridiculous and out-of-order.  and for this WG
to even discuss it is a waste of this group's energy.

we have wasted enough time with this already; we need to stop this
nonsense now.  if there are real problems that we need to solve, let's
solve them, but propagating SL is not part of the solution space.

Keith

> I am looking to have the declaration of consensus repealed. It doesn't
> matter if that is done voluntarily by the chair's, or external
> directive. We can't allow chairs to be declaring consensus when no
> one, including the chair, knows the meaning of the question.