Re: GMPLS MIBs

[Len Nieman <lwnieman@bellsouth.net>]

>All I have just posted an update to the GMPLS MIB modules.
>The model followed is to extend the MPLS MIB modules.
>
>At the moment the drafts are VERY rough, but we wanted to publish
>them so that the WG can see the direction we are taking and
>comment accordingly. In particular:
>
>- no attempt at compilation has yet been made

I ran compiles on the drafts listed using the MG-SOFT MIB
Compiler (MS Windows Edition) Version 5.0 RC1, Build 110.

Prior to attempting this I compiled the appropriate MPLS MIB
modules from the most recent mpls drafts. It wasn't included in
your list, but I also compiled the LMP-MIB module from
draft-ietf-ccamp-lmp-mib-06.txt while I was at it.

The results were:

draft-ietf-ccamp-gmpls-tc-mib-01.txt

- GMPLS-TC-MIB module: Compiled okay after substituting the ifType
value of "166" for the "xxx" here:

   gmplsStdMIB OBJECT IDENTIFIER
     -- This object identifier needs to be assigned by IANA.
     -- Since mpls has been assigned an ifType of 166 we recommend
     -- that this OID be 166 as well, i.e.
   -- ::= { transmission XXX }
   ::= { transmission 166 }

========================================

draft-ietf-ccamp-gmpls-lsr-mib-01.txt

- GMPLS-LABEL-STD-MIB module: Compiled okay after adding a second
dash in front of the "The MPLS LSR MIB" comment here:

     MODULE MPLS-LSR-STD-MIB - The MPLS LSR MIB

- GMPLS-LSR-STD-MIB module: Compiled okay after correcting three
instances of "SYNTAX Uunsigned32" to "SYNTAX Unsigned32" at these
locations:

   gmplsLabelWavebandId OBJECT-TYPE
     SYNTAX        Uunsigned32

   gmplsLabelWavebandStart OBJECT-TYPE
     SYNTAX        Uunsigned32

   gmplsLabelWavebandEnd OBJECT-TYPE
     SYNTAX        Uunsigned32

===========================================

draft-ietf-ccamp-gmpls-te-mib-01.txt

- GMPLS-TE-MIB module:

Error "Item 'MplsTunnelARHopEntry' is not defined or imported"
at:

   gmplsTunnelARHopEntry  OBJECT-TYPE
     SYNTAX  MplsTunnelARHopEntry

Error "Item 'DisplayString' is not defined or imported at:

   GmplsTunnelErrorEntry ::= SEQUENCE {
     gmplsTunnelErrorHelpString         DisplayString

Error "Missing 'ACCESS or MAX-ACCESS" being created by an extraneous
comma at the end of the SYNTAX line at:

   gmplsTunnelErrorReporterIpv6Addr OBJECT-TYPE
     SYNTAX  InetAddressIPv6,
     MAX-ACCESS read-only

===============================================

draft-ietf-ccamp-lmp-mib-06.txt

- LMP-MIB module: Compiled okay after substituting the
experimental value of "113" for the "xxx" here:

   DESCRIPTION
       "Initial version published as RFC xxxx (to be assigned by RFC
        Editor)"
   ::= { mib-2 xxx } -- To be assigned by IANA (experimental 113 can
                     -- be used in the interim)

=================================================

Len Nieman