Re: [idn] Future of the requirements document

[Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine <brunner@nic-naa.net>]

James,

> The decision to drop requirements is explained in the wg chairs
> statement and is independent of your appeal.

Chairs do not decide, they attempt to observe and correctly state the
rough consensus of a working group.

> But your (and David) volunteer to take over as editor of requirements is
> also noted. Nevertheless, the value of requirements is lesser now and it
> is agreed in Salt Lake to drop the requirements. (Minutes will be
> available soon).

Face to face meetings do not decide, they reach (or don't) some consensus,
which the working group may (or may not) affirm, again, by rough consensus.

Eric