[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
RE: review for: draft-ietf-ospf-mib-update-09.txt [wasRE: PRELIMI NARY Agenda and Package for April 13, 2006 Telechat ]
Yes, but I believe those are all because this is basically an update
to the old (SMIv1) RFC1850 MIB module.
Adding some text to indeed explain that so that one does not get
the wrong impression when trying to compile, that would be usefull.
Bert
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Romascanu, Dan (Dan) [mailto:dromasca@avaya.com]
> Sent: Sunday, April 09, 2006 13:09
> To: Wijnen, Bert (Bert); Bill Fenner (E-mail)
> Cc: Mreview (E-mail)
> Subject: RE: review for: draft-ietf-ospf-mib-update-09.txt [wasRE:
> PRELIMINARY Agenda and Package for April 13, 2006 Telechat ]
>
>
> smilint complains of the following:
>
> This is an automatically generated mail message in response to a mail
> message you (or someone else who used your address) sent to
> <smilint@ibr.cs.tu-bs.de>.
> If you want to learn more about this mail service, send a mail message
> with the "Subject: help" to <smilint@ibr.cs.tu-bs.de>.
>
> The program smilint 0.4.3, as of Fri Apr 07 09:10:01 2006 has
> been used
> to process your request as follows:
>
> smilint -m -s -e -l 6 OSPF-MIB OSPF-TRAP-MIB
>
> OSPF-MIB:667: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAreaId' of row `ospfAreaEntry' should be not-accessible in SMIv2
> MIB
> OSPF-MIB:921: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfStubAreaId' of row `ospfStubAreaEntry' should be
> not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:921: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfStubTOS' of row `ospfStubAreaEntry' should be not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1026: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfLsdbAreaId' of row `ospfLsdbEntry' should be not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1026: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfLsdbType' of row `ospfLsdbEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2
> MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1026: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfLsdbLsid' of row `ospfLsdbEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2
> MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1026: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfLsdbRouterId' of row `ospfLsdbEntry' should be not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1200: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAreaRangeAreaId' of row `ospfAreaRangeEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1200: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAreaRangeNet' of row `ospfAreaRangeEntry' should be
> not-accessible
> in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1308: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfHostIpAddress' of row `ospfHostEntry' should be not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1308: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfHostTOS' of row `ospfHostEntry' should be not-accessible in SMIv2
> MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1418: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfIfIpAddress' of row `ospfIfEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2
> MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1418: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAddressLessIf' of row `ospfIfEntry' should be not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1852: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfIfMetricIpAddress' of row `ospfIfMetricEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1852: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfIfMetricAddressLessIf' of row `ospfIfMetricEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1852: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfIfMetricTOS' of row `ospfIfMetricEntry' should be
> not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1956: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfVirtIfAreaId' of row `ospfVirtIfEntry' should be
> not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:1956: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfVirtIfNeighbor' of row `ospfVirtIfEntry' should be not-accessible
> in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2197: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfNbrIpAddr' of row `ospfNbrEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2
> MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2197: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfNbrAddressLessIndex' of row `ospfNbrEntry' should be
> not-accessible
> in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2455: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfVirtNbrArea' of row `ospfVirtNbrEntry' should be
> not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2455: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfVirtNbrRtrId' of row `ospfVirtNbrEntry' should be
> not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2647: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfExtLsdbType' of row `ospfExtLsdbEntry' should be
> not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2647: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfExtLsdbLsid' of row `ospfExtLsdbEntry' should be
> not-accessible in
> SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2647: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfExtLsdbRouterId' of row `ospfExtLsdbEntry' should be
> not-accessible
> in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2850: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAreaAggregateAreaID' of row `ospfAreaAggregateEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2850: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAreaAggregateLsdbType' of row `ospfAreaAggregateEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2850: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAreaAggregateNet' of row `ospfAreaAggregateEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-MIB:2850: [5] {index-element-accessible} warning: index element
> `ospfAreaAggregateMask' of row `ospfAreaAggregateEntry' should be
> not-accessible in SMIv2 MIB
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:21: [4] {module-identity-registration} warning:
> uncontrolled MODULE-IDENTITY registration
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:161: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfVirtIfStateChange' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:178: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfNbrStateChange' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:201: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfVirtNbrStateChange' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:217: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfIfConfigError' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:236: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfVirtIfConfigError' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:254: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfIfAuthFailure' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:273: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfVirtIfAuthFailure' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:290: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfIfRxBadPacket' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:304: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfVirtIfRxBadPacket' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:317: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfTxRetransmit' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:337: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfVirtIfTxRetransmit' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:356: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfOriginateLsa' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:376: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfMaxAgeLsa' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:390: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfLsdbOverflow' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:401: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfLsdbApproachingOverflow' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:413: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfIfStateChange' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:430: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfNssaTranslatorStatusChange' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:445: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfRestartStatusChange' is not reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:460: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfNbrRestartHelperStatusChange' is not
> reverse mappable
> OSPF-TRAP-MIB:478: [5] {notification-not-reversible} warning:
> notification `ospfVirtNbrRestartHelperStatusChange' is not reverse
> mappable
>
> Additional descriptions of some error/warning messages:
>
> Warning: module-identity-registration (level 4)
> Message: uncontrolled MODULE-IDENTITY registration
> Description: The identities of IETF MIB modules should be registered
> below
> mib-2, transmission, or snmpModules so that the
> registration
> space can be controlled by IANA.
>
> Is this a result of the backwards compatibility with the original
> version of the MIB?. That's fine, but should not a note be included
> acknowledging this, so that people who compile in the future
> understand
> what is the problem, and do not start asking questions?
>
> Same, I would include a note about the very 'traps-centric' language
> used in OSPF-TRAP-MIB which I guess also has some kind of historic
> context.
>
> Dan
>
>
>
>
>
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: Wijnen, Bert (Bert) [mailto:bwijnen@lucent.com]
> > Sent: Saturday, April 08, 2006 4:17 PM
> > To: Romascanu, Dan (Dan); Bill Fenner (E-mail)
> > Cc: Mreview (E-mail)
> > Subject: review for: draft-ietf-ospf-mib-update-09.txt
> > [wasRE: PRELIMINARY Agenda and Package for April 13, 2006 Telechat ]
> >
> > Dan, I reviewed this one back in November as MIB Doctor.
> > My comments have been addressed and/or answered.
> >
> > So basically I am basically happy with this one.
> >
> > But I see:
> > E: f(ospftrap.mi2), (518,22) Group "ospfTrapControlGroup" is
> > both a MANDATORY and conditional group for module "OSPF-TRAP-MIB"
> > I think it is OK, because of the 2 module compliance statements.
> >
> > A few nits remain (RFC-Editor can fix):
> >
> > !! Missing Reference for citation: [24]
> > P086 L046: explained in RFC 1224 [24]. The basic
> > premise of the throttling
> >
> > !! Missing citation for Informative reference:
> > P101 L011: [RFC1765] Moy, J., "OSPF Database
> > Overflow", RFC 1765, March 1995.
> >
> > !! Missing citation for Informative reference:
> > P101 L013: [RFC1793] Moy, J., "Extending OSPF to
> > Support Demand Circuits",
> >
> > !! Missing citation for Informative reference:
> > P101 L019: [RFC2328] Moy, J., "OSPF Version 2", RFC
> > 2328, April 1998.
> >
> > !! Missing citation for Informative reference:
> > P101 L021: [RFC2370] Coltun, R., "The OSPF Opaque LSA
> > Option", RFC 2370,
> >
> > !! Missing citation for Normative reference:
> > P100 L055: [RFC2863] McCloghrie, K., Kastenholtz, F.,
> >
> > !! Missing citation for Informative reference:
> > P101 L024: [RFC3101] Murphy, P., "The OSPF
> > Not-So-Stubby Area (NSSA) Option",
> >
> > Bert
> >
> > > -----Original Message-----
> > > From: owner-mreview@ops.ietf.org
> > [mailto:owner-mreview@ops.ietf.org]On
> > > Behalf Of Romascanu, Dan (Dan)
> > > Sent: Friday, April 07, 2006 10:07
> > > To: Mreview (E-mail)
> > > Subject: FW: PRELIMINARY Agenda and Package for April 13,
> > > 2006 Telechat
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > > Below is the preliminary agenda for the April 13, 2006 IESG
> > telechat.
> > > Please review the documents that are of interest for you and our
> > > group, and let me know any comments and issues until
> > Wednesday April
> > > 12, COB the latest.
> > >
> > > Thanks and Regards,
> > >
> > > Dan
> >
>