Re: Defintion of Automatic tunnels

[Erik Nordmark <Erik.Nordmark@sun.com>]

> This is an interesting discussion of the issues (well, it was, but
> I deleted it to save bits). But I'm not sure that the WG has to, or
> should, make a choice. The network is already telling us that both
> tunnel brokers and 6to4 attract users. I guess the jury is still out
> on Teredo. But I don't think it's for us to make a philosophical
> decision here. We will need to decide whether to adopt Teredo, but that
> should drop out of the scenario analysis as a pragmatic decision.

Brian,

You seem to be making a "the market will decide" argument with respect
to 6to4 and tunnel brokers.
Is that correct?

I find it disconcerting that you didn't want to contribute to the understanding
of the issues (with apply to all tunneling approaches - 6to4, teredo, tunnel
brokers) and instead deleted the email to "save bits". That doesn't bode well
for making forward progress.

Sigh
  Erik