evaluation: draft-ietf-dnsext-dnssec-2535typecode-change-04.txt

[hardie@qualcomm.com]

Ted Hardie          [   ]     [ x  ]       [   ]      [   ]

Notes:

In the IANA considerations:

   In order to allow DNS Security and SIG(0) to use different sets of
   algorithms, the existing "DNS Security Algorithm Numbers" registry
   is renamed as the "SIG(0) Algorithm Numbers" registry and a new
   "DNS Security Algorithm Numbers" registry is established.  The
   initial algorithm values are:

Given the care to avoid collisions, it seems a bit odd to reuse the
same name for the  IANA registry, and I'd suggest making some
change to the name.  Given that the old registry has some values
(0,1, 4, and 252) that are not registered by this document, the
two are not exactly congruent even though none of those registered
by this document are in conflict with that registry.  This could
be worked out with IANA and made and RFC Editor note, though.