The following table gives a list of known issues that await resolution for the Internet Draft draft-ietf-mobileip-rfc3012bis-04.txt ("Mobile IPv4 Challenge/Response Extensions").
The Status field marks the issues as given by the below list.
New issues can be submitted by sending an e-mail to the WG mailing list, clearly stating that there is a problem in the specification. I'll also try to create issue descriptions as the discussions go on.
Issue # | Status | Draft # | Description |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Rejected | ..-04 | Vulnerability to bogus registration replies? |
2 | Rejected | ..-04 | SHOULD or MUST for the Challenge extension to the Registration Request message? |
3 | Adopted | ..-04 | Handling for STALE_CHALLENGE? Extract the challenge from a registration reply with an error? |
4 | Adopted | ..-04 | Does the MN need to track which FAs have issued which challenge? |
5 | Adopted | ..-04 | How does a foreign agent decide whether or not the challenge extension is needed? |
6 | Adopted | ..-04 | What happens when the reply is lost between the FA and MN? |
7 | Rejected | ..-04 | Why not have the "keep N+1 challenge values" apply to the values sent in both advertisements and replies? |
8 | Rejected | ..-04 | Is an FA implementing this specification is allowed to interoperate with pre-existing HAs? |
9 | Rejected | ..-04 | WHy is the Mobile-Foreign challenge carried between the FA and HA? |
10 | Adopted | ..-04 | What checks (if any) does the HA perform on the received registration request? |
11 | Rejected | ..-04 | Why should a pre-existing Home Agent send a Registration Reply to the Foreign Agent if it will be rejected anyway? |
12 | Rejected | ..-04 | IANA consideration does not mention subtype in section 5. |
13 | Rejected | ..-04 | Format of Generalized Mobile IP Authentication Extension. |
14 | Adopted | ..-04 | How many bits of length and SPI are fed into MD5? |
15 | Rejected | ..-04 | A node might fool a mobile node into acting as if its registration were rejected. |
16 | Rejected | ..-04 | Bogus registration replies must be accepted because the mobile node cannot tell and it needs the challenge. |
This is some text at the end. It's not really needed.