Re: FW: AD response to Site-Local Appeal

[Leif Johansson <leifj@it.su.se>]

Tony Hain wrote:

> Keith Moore wrote:
>  
> > Tony,
> >
> > there was strong concensus in the WG to deprecate SL. 
> >    
> No, there was a question asked where there would be multiple undefined
> meanings for a Yes vote, and multiple undefined meanings for a No vote.
> Basically a blank check for the chair to tell the WG what it had decided.
>
>  
On the contrary, I believe that there was strong consensus about the 
nature of
the question. In fact (as I recall) at the meeting in SF there was 
signifficant
discussion about the question posed - there was ample opportunity to 
clear up
any remaining confusion about the question posed.

      MVH leifj