RE: Proposal from mstjohns: Pre-approval of RFC 2727bis

[Harald Tveit Alvestrand <harald@alvestrand.no>]

After listening to the misgivings and worries mentioned by Ted, Margaret, 
Steve and Thomas, I've concluded that we should not go forward on this path.

We've uncovered *another* issue with the document, however: The document 
does not say when it goes into effect, or what happens to any nomcom that 
is active at the time.

It may be at:
- IESG approval
- ISOC Board approval
- Document publication (probably unreasonable)

and the effect may be:
- current nomcom changes its rules and attempts to conform retroactively 
(ie multiple members resign)
- current nomcom changes its rules for actions taken after this point, as 
far as possible (ie no resignation)
- current nomcom sticks to the rules in effect at its creation

I thought the second one was obvious until someone pointed out that the 
third one is possibly reasonable too.

It probably needs to be debated. Sigh.

                     Harald