Re: Evaluation: draft-zhao-slp-remote-da-discovery - Finding Rem oteDirectory Agents and Service Agents in the Service Location Protocol via DNSSRV to Proposed Standard

[ned.freed@mrochek.com]

> Right, depending on usage, this can create either a circular or spiral
> dependency between SLP and DNS, and the doc neither warns about thsi
> nor gives one enough information to tell how likely it is to happen.

> As far as I could tell from reading the doc, the DNS names are a
> "given" (ie, they come out of thin air :).

What appears to be missing is any sense of what the service architecture of
"Internet-wide SLP" looks like or how it should be used.

				Ned